What Insurance Auditors Look for in Transportation Companies
What Insurance Auditors Look for in Transportation Companies
Insurance audits can feel intimidating—but they’re a normal part of running a transportation business. Whether you operate a small fleet of taxis, provide non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT), or manage a shuttle service, your commercial insurer will likely conduct annual audits to verify that your coverage, operations, and risk profile are still accurate.
Understanding what auditors are looking for not only helps you avoid penalties and premium increases, but also ensures you’re properly protected and operating legally.
1. Accurate Vehicle and Driver Records
One of the first things insurance auditors request is a list of active vehicles and drivers under your policy.
They want to see:
- Current registration and VINs for all insured vehicles
- Proof of regular maintenance or inspections
- Driver’s licenses, MVRs, and training documentation
- Updated list of any new or removed vehicles or drivers
Tip: Keep an organized folder (physical or digital) with updated driver and vehicle files. Make sure only eligible, approved drivers are operating under your policy.
2. Actual Business Use and Miles Driven
Insurance premiums are often based on how your vehicles are used and how much they’re on the road. If your business activity has changed significantly, your insurer needs to know.
Auditors will check for:
- Mileage logs for each vehicle
- Type of services provided (passenger transport, delivery, NEMT, etc.)
- Service radius or territories covered
- Any changes in business type or operational scope
Misclassifying business use (e.g., listing your service as local when you operate regionally) can result in premium adjustments or denial of claims.
3. Employee Classification and Payroll Records
For policies that include workers’ compensation or liability tied to payroll, insurance auditors will want to verify:
- Total payroll for drivers and office staff
- Roles and job descriptions for each employee
- Whether any independent contractors should be classified as employees
- Overtime or seasonal staffing changes
Tip: Use consistent job codes and track payroll clearly. Misclassifying workers can result in serious penalties—not just higher premiums.
4. Certificates of Insurance for Subcontractors
If you use independent drivers or subcontract out transportation work, your insurer wants to know if you’re liable for their actions.
What they want:
- Proof of active commercial auto and liability insurance for all subcontractors
- Clear written contracts outlining who is responsible in case of an accident
- Certificates of Insurance (COIs) naming your business as an additional insured, when applicable
Tip: Always collect COIs and file them before allowing a subcontractor to take any trips under your brand.
5. Claims History and Incident Reports
If you’ve had any accidents, damages, or customer complaints, your insurer wants documentation.
What to provide:
- Copies of filed claims and resolutions
- Driver incident reports and any retraining completed
- Vehicle repair documentation
- Dashcam footage if applicable
Transparency builds trust with your insurer—and a clean, well-documented claims history can help keep your premiums in check.
6. Compliance with Industry Regulations
Your insurer wants assurance that you’re operating within the law. That includes local, state, and federal regulations depending on your fleet size and service type.
Auditors may ask for:
- DOT registration and inspection records (if applicable)
- TLC, PUC, or local taxi authority licenses
- Drug testing compliance for drivers (especially in NEMT or interstate operations)
- ADA compliance documentation for accessible vehicles
Tip: Set calendar reminders to renew licenses and conduct regular internal audits to stay ahead of violations.
Final Thoughts: Audits Are About Risk—Not Punishment
Insurance audits aren't meant to trap you—they’re a routine way for insurers to assess risk, confirm accuracy, and ensure you're properly covered. If you're organized, transparent, and compliant, the process is straightforward—and it can actually help you avoid overpaying.
Need Help Preparing for an Insurance Audit or Review?
Drive Logic Fleet works with transportation business owners to build reliable, audit-ready systems that save time and reduce liability.
Schedule a consultation today to protect your fleet, your drivers, and your bottom line—before the next audit notice arrives.





